MTGFinance: What We’re Buying & Selling This Week (Aug 24/15)

By James Chillcott (@MTGCritic)

One of the most common misconceptions about folks involved in MTGFinance is that we are constantly manipulating the market and feeding players misinformation to help fuel achievement of our personal goals.

It has occurred to us at MTGPrice that though we dole out a good deal of advice, most of you ultimately have very little insight into when and why our writing team actually puts our money where our collective mouths are pointing. As such running this weekly series breaking down what we’ve been buying and selling each week and why. These lists are meant to be both complete and transparent, leaving off only cards we bought for personal use without hope of profit. We’ll also try to provide some insight into our thinking behind the specs, and whether we are aiming for a short (<1 month), mid (1-12 month), or long (1 year+) term flip. Here’s what we we’ve been up to this week:

Buying Period: Aug 11th – Aug 20th, 2015

Note: All cards NM unless otherwise noted. All sell prices are net of fees unless noted.

James Chillcott (@MTGCritic)

Coming off of my tour of lovely Bulgaria and Turkey I haven’t been in buying mode, but I did pick up a few things here and there.


  • 1x Hangarback Walker (Foil) @ $25
  • 1x Russian Magic Origins Booster Box @ $109

Hangarback Walker expanded its horizons this weekend at Eternal Weekend showing up in the finals of the Vintage Championships in a Workshop deck. The card has now demonstrated viability in almost every relevant format and I’m happy to pick up more foils anywhere under $25 since Origins will ultimately have lower sales than a major fall set and the card is often a 4-of wherever it pops up. I see this is as a mid to long term hold with a $40+ target.

The Russian Origins box is my vote of confidence that Origins may actually end up producing more than a few Modern and Eternal relevant cards (Hangarback Walker, Dark Petition, Jace, Vrynn’s Prodigy, Evolutionary Leap, etc) that may be highly desirable in Russian foil down the road. This is a long term hold, targeting $200+.

I’ll be posting my report on Magic in Bulgaria and Turkey later this week, so watch for that.

Travis Allen (@WizardBumpin)


  • 35x Dragon Whisperer @ $2/per
  • 9x Shaman of the Forgotten Ways @ $2.25/per
  • 23x Tasigur, the Golden Fang (foil) @ $30/per
  • 8x Whisperwood Elemental @ $5.50/per
  • 14x Sarkhan, the Dragonspeaker @ $4/per
  • 30x Wingmate Roc @ $1.50/per
  • 8x Woodland Bellower @ $4/per

“Dragon Whisperer is an extremely cheap mythic red two-drop from a third set. Power level is high. She’s only made a splash so far, but red is saturated right now. Come rotation she could easily be the best red two in the format.”

“Shaman plays well with the coming Eldrazi, and is a third-set mythic. Could break $10.”

“Re: Tasigur, a while ago I noticed that foil Abrupt Decays were about $30. The nonfoils were around $7 – $10 at the time. My suspicion was that $30 was too cheap, especially for how much eternal play they saw. I picked up two extra playsets. Within two weeks, they had spiked to $80, and I was wishing I had bought more. With Tasigur’s ubiquity across formats, I’m not making the same mistake again. He’s possibly the best black creature in Standard, Modern, and Legacy. While a non-foil reprint would harm his price, foils are going to be quite safe. I’m looking for this one to at least double by the spring of 2016.”

“Whisperwood Elemental was $15 not that long ago, and all the cards that make him good (Den Protector, Deathmist Raptor, and Mastery of the Unseen) are all sticking around through rotation. I’d like to buy more if he ends up under $4.”

“Sarkhan is a $4 Planeswalker with a solid power level. He’s mostly been pushed out of Standard by Stormbreath Dragon, but that guy is leaving us soon.”

“Wingmate Roc used to be $15-$20. He’s at bulk mythic pricing now, and could certainly be a major Standard player again later this year.”

“Woodland Bellower demonstrated notable power during the Pro Tour. With no price movement so far, a breakout performance could send this skyrocketing.”

Jim Casale (@Phrost_)


  • 4x Anafenza, the Foremost @ $3.50/per
  • 4x Tragic Arrogance (foil) @ $3.00/per
  • 4x Abrupt Decay @ $8.00/per

Jim says:

Anafenza, the Foremost is down to $3.50 from $7.00 before the release of Dragons of Tarkir. It’s also 12 tickets on MTGO which is usually a good indicator of play. There are some other factors at work (mythics command a larger portion of a set’s price due to redemption online) but I think this card is going to be one of the few cards to rebound during BFZ. 

Tragic Arrogance is the real deal in standard and it is also quite powerful in EDH. I decided to grab foil copies to play with as they will likely retain more of their value as time goes on. The spread on foil and non-foil copies is closing pretty quickly so this may even see a price correction in the near future.

Regarding Abrupt Decay, I found a player that wanted to sell some cards for quick cash. I offered him more than local buylist and he accepted. Hard to pass up this kind of deal.

BOUGHT (PucaTrade)

  • 4x Ghostfire Blade @ 175 Pucapoints/per

Jim says:

“The Eldrazi will probably all be “colorless” despite costing colored mana. Ghostfire Blade was pretty good with thopters so I can’t see it getting worse with more colorless creatures.”


  • 3x Jace, Vryn’s Prodigy @ $30/per
  • 1x Creeping Tarpit (foil) @ $30/per

Jim says:

“Jace was sold to a local player looking to play the Majors/Cuneo mill deck this week. The price included no fees so its hard to pass up a deal this good. I think I will likely be able to buy them back in a month or two for $20 or less.”

“Creeping Tarpit was sold to a player (so no additional fees) and I’m pretty sure the manlands will be reprinted sometime in the next year or two and there is no real reason to keep this.”

SOLD (Puca)

  • 8x ghostfire blade @ 112 pucapoints/copy

Danny Brown (@dbro37)


  • 20x Narset, Enlightened Tutor $1.24/per
  • 4x Sarkhan, the Dragon Speaker @ $5.40/per
  • 8x Dragon Whisperer $2.25/per
  • 1x Daretti, Scrap Savant $3.44/per
  • 1x Outpost Siege $1.08/per

Danny says:

“I discussed Narset in my article this week, and all 20 copies I requested were sent pretty quickly. I also discussed Sarkhan and wasn’t sold at that time, but I pulled the trigger on a playset and will probably try for another couple.”

Dragon Whisperer is a mythic that may be forced to step up if mono red continues to be a thing in Standard. I think this has enough casual appeal that it could be a slow gainer in the long term, as well. It reminds me of Kargan Dragonlord in many ways, which is $7, so I think the risk is low. One copy will probably go in my cube.”

Daretti is a great pick-up right now and people seem to know. I think I had 16 on my list and only one got sent.”

“The Outpost Siege is for my cube, though it’s likely starting in the on-deck binder until/if I decide to expand or switch up some strategies. Some Standard play and a spike could turn this into a (very) minor spec, though.”


Jared Yost

Here is my buying for this week:

  • 10x Polluted Delta @ $21.00/per
  • 10x Flooded Strand @ $15.78/per
  • 10x Bloodstained Mire @ $18.71/per

“I found some great deals through Amazon, and using some of my Amazon points that I’ve been accumulating I thought I would put them to use by picking up some much needed Fetchlands for my portfolio. I really needed Strands and Deltas, as I’ve been steadily trading for Heaths, Foothills, and Mires over the summer to build up a nice stockpile.”

So there you have it. Now what were you guys buying and selling this week and why?

James Chillcott is the CEO of, The Future of Collecting, Senior Partner at Advoca, a designer, adventurer, toy fanatic and an avid Magic player and collector since 1994.

ADVERTISEMENT: Get the Cube Starter Bundle with the 3rd Edition Grimoire Deck Box, the brand new Grimoire Deck Box designed specifically for the red mage in you.

11 thoughts on “MTGFinance: What We’re Buying & Selling This Week (Aug 24/15)”

  1. Hey everyone,
    Here’s my list from the last 2 weeks:
    1 Keranos, God of Storms Foil $45
    1 Pharika, God of Affliction Foil $9
    2 Thoughtseize THS $17.50 each
    24 Evolutionary Leap $ 2.14 each
    2 Abrupt Decay $14 each
    2 Polluted Delta KTR $21 each
    2 Flooded Strand KTR $15 each
    2 Wooded Foothills KTR $11.5 each
    2 Bloodstained Mire KTR $10 each
    No sell list, Rally & Ojutai’s Command have crapped the bed.

      1. CoolstuffInc is running there Legacy sale til the end of the month. Plus I get a discount for spending so much there over the last 6 months. They did have Polluted Deltas for $20 but they changed that in a hurry when customers with a high discount started buying them up. I could have bought some for $17.50 each but I missed out. They still have Foothills for $13 each without store bonus.

  2. Not a buy, but I traded 7500 bulk cards, including 250 bulk rares, for the following:

    2x Polluted Delta
    1x Flooded Strand
    2x Wooded Foothills

    The rest of the bulk was mostly commons and basic lands, and only about 1200 uncommons. It was a nice overhaul of my collection, and I turned it into Khans fetches. Feels good.

  3. Even after the 1st jump with PT Vancouver and all MonoRed, I’m very positive on Abbot of Kher Keep if there is a home in Modern for him.

    Last weekend in SCG the winner decklist was playing 1 in Jund. I see no reason why this couldn’t play as well in some aggro Zoo lists, Burn or an aggro version of R/U/x delver without counterspells. If so, it could easily skyrocket.
    See as comparison Kolaghan’s command, which plays as 1x or 2x in a few decks, is multicoloroed and is steadily at $10.
    I’m very bullish on this guy, specially foil copies.

  4. Buys
    10x SDCC 2015 Planeswalkers sets 200-225 shipped each (eBay)
    4x Jeskai Charm(foil) 322pp each
    4x Sword of the Animist 1156pp each
    8x See the Unwritten (foil) 955pp each
    12x See the Unwritten 544pp each
    8x Monastery Mentor 1604pp each
    WTB! 4x Monastery Mentor(foil) 5000pp each

    8x Inquisition of Kozilek 1334pp (purchased for $8.00 each)
    8x Hangarback Walkers(foil) $26-28 each (eBay. Bought 13 for 2000pp)

    I feel Monastery Mentor is good in Modern and sees some legacy play. Inquisition of Kozilek could be reprinted in BFZ. Walker hype has died a bit, I’m expecting it to decline to $15. See the Unwritten for cheating Eldrazis into play(hopefully). The SDCC black walkers seem to always be a good buy. Get them now while they’re still cheap. All of the walkers are playable in tiny leaders and huge casual demand for EDH. Jace is going eternal and Liliana is seeing a ton of play.

  5. Hello,

    I am no one in particular on this site, but I thought i’d share my purchases for the this week:

    Just upped my quantities on See the Unwritten and Dragon Whisperer

    See the Unwritten : 31 x 4,99$ (now hold 71 copies) at about 4$ per copy
    Dragon Whisperer : 23 non foil x 2,49$; 10 foil x 5,99$

    Like stating the obvious, there is a fantasy for these two cards in the future standard, as they may fill in a specific need/advantage (great 2 drop, and solid “sneak in a card and win”).

    Regardless if they see play or not, I believe the hype alone will push these guys up. And if they do see play after rotation/BFZ … 🙂
    Simply my 2 cents

Comments are closed.